Choosing between a new set of thumbsticks, a phone clip, a used working controller, and a broken-for-parts controller isn't always straightforward. The $10.99 to $24.99 price range looks small, but the real difference is whether you already have a controller that works. If you do, the $10.99 KontrolFreek Galaxy thumbsticks are the quickest way to change how your controller feels. If you don't, the used Microsoft controller is priced well below the non-working Heart Breaker while still being fully functional.
Quick take: Buy the KontrolFreek Galaxy thumbsticks if you want to change the feel of a controller you already own. Buy the 8Bitdo Mobile Gaming Clip if your goal is mobile play. Buy the Microsoft Model 1708 if you need a used controller that works. Avoid the Heart Breaker unless you're shopping for a non-working unit.
Here's the price and purpose at a glance.
| Product | Listed Price | Price Bar | What It Is | Good For |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| KontrolFreek FPS Freek Galaxy Thumbsticks Xbox Series X|S One Black + One New | $10.99 | Two performance thumbsticks with a concave design | Improving grip and aim on an existing controller | |
| Heart Breaker Wireless Controller Series X|S One (PLEASE READ) | $24.99 | Wireless controller listed as not working | Donor use only | |
| 8Bitdo Mobile Gaming Clip for Xbox One Wireless and Elite Series Controllers New | $13.99 | Clip that attaches a phone to an Xbox controller | Phone-based gameplay while using a controller | |
| Fully Working Microsoft Xbox One Wireless Controller White/Black Model 1708 | $14.99 | Used wireless controller listed as working | A spare/primary controller |
Decision matrix:
- Already have a controller and want better stick control? The KontrolFreek thumbsticks add one high-rise and one mid-rise concave stick.
- Want to play with your phone screen while using a controller? The 8Bitdo clip attaches the phone to the top of the controller.
- Need a second working controller for another player? The Microsoft Model 1708 is a used wireless option listed as fully working.
- Need a controller shell, buttons, or sticks for a rebuild? The Heart Breaker is a wireless controller sold as non-working.
KontrolFreek FPS Freek Galaxy Thumbsticks Xbox Series X|S One Black + One New
The Galaxy kit comes with two performance thumbsticks, one high-rise and one mid-rise, so you can mix heights between the left and right stick. The concave tops and textured surface are aimed at improving grip, comfort, and aiming accuracy in shooters and action games. Compatibility includes Xbox Series X|S and Xbox One controllers, with a black finish that matches most gamepads. If you already have a working controller, this kit is an easy way to change its feel without replacing the whole unit. The limitation is that it's only an attachment: you still need a controller, and it doesn't add wireless capability or fix any existing stick problems.
Heart Breaker Wireless Controller Series X|S One (PLEASE READ)
The Heart Breaker is a controller with a pink, purple, and blue color scheme, but it's listed as for parts or not working. Left stick drift is noted, while all other buttons function properly. That makes it a donor controller for someone who needs a shell, buttons, or a wireless board, not a gamepad for actual play. It's the most expensive item in this group, which is a serious catch: a working used controller costs less. Buy it only if you specifically want a repair base and are comfortable with the drifty stick condition.
8Bitdo Mobile Gaming Clip for Xbox One Wireless and Elite Series Controllers New
The 8Bitdo clip is a black mobile gaming clip for Xbox One and Elite Series controllers. It lets you attach your phone to the top of the controller, making it easier to see your phone screen while you use the controller. It's listed as new and includes a clip design that attaches to the controller. Black construction helps it blend with most Xbox controllers. The clip is a practical add-on for anyone who wants a full-size controller with a phone attached. The limitation is that it only works as a mount; you still need a controller and a phone, and it doesn't do anything for stick feel or controller function.
Fully Working Microsoft Xbox One Wireless Controller White/Black Model 1708
This used Microsoft Xbox One controller in a white and black finish is identified as Model 1708. It's described as fully working, with stick-drift readings well below the drift threshold. It arrives with no other accessories, so you're getting just the gamepad. If you need a working spare without spending as much as the non-working Heart Breaker, this is the more sensible buy. The limitation is that it's used, only works on Xbox One, and doesn't come with a cable or batteries.
Final recommendation by use case:
- For most setups where a controller already exists, put the money into the KontrolFreek thumbsticks for an immediate feel change.
- For phone-first play, the 8Bitdo clip is the right add-on.
- For local multiplayer or a backup gamepad, choose the used Microsoft Model 1708; it costs less than the for-parts Heart Breaker and is the safer functional pick.
- For a repair project, the Heart Breaker is the only donor controller here, but only if you're willing to work around the left stick drift.
